"My Secret Genies" is the first episode of Shimmer and Shine. It consists of two parts, which were produced as separate episodes.
"Leah wins a genie bottle necklace at a carnival and is surprised to find that her prize comes with a bonus – genies Shimmer and Shine. Leah makes a silly wish for a polka-dotted elephant."
- This episode was advertised as a double-length special under the title "The First Wish".
- Despite being the first two episodes produced, the two parts of "My Secret Genies" were the last episodes of the first season aired in the United States.
- This episode reveals that if a person tells someone that he or she has a genie, they will lose their genie, forever.
- It started in flashback that how Shimmer, Shine and Leah met for the first time and the scrapbook from "Happy Wishaversary" for their memories.
- Eva Bella as Shimmer
- Isabella Crovetti-Cramp as Shine
- Alina Foley as Leah
- Blake Bertrand as Zac
- Dee Bradley Baker as Tala / Nahal / Dotty
- Miles Hoff as Attendant
- Melanie Fontana as Session Singer
- Bottle Quest
- Magic Mirror
- Make a Wish
- Mistake Song
- Carnival Song
- Travel Back